As we know, not all students have the same academic/personal backgrounds as witnessed in one of my current classes. In this class, one of the students has lived in an elite boarding school and regularly meets with dignitaries including the Queen of England while another student has never had the opportunity to leave South Carolina. The educational background and basic skills differences can sometimes be quite apparent. This disparity can bring an unlevel playing field into your classroom and dumbfound a faculty member who is trying to grade each one fairly and equality. I believe that everyone can learn and succeed, but they have to have the tools to do it.
I incorporate blogs, wikis and discussion boards into my classes. While some of my students have used these features in high school, others have not. Many think that replying or posting online means leaving jokes, scathing comments or “one-liners” like “I agree with Bill”. This certainly puts a damper on the quality of the discussions.
One way to make sure that everyone is on a level playing field and to encourage meaningful participation is to use a rubric. A rubric is a scoring or assessment tool which can help faculty and students score/grade the quality of the academic material based on set criteria. Being introduced to a rubric, students can then know how they will be graded and learn what they need to do in order to succeed. The grading rubric can be used for blogs, discussion boards, wikis, and modified for classroom discussions. Whether you assess each post, blog, etc. on its own individual value, is up to the faculty member. I personally evaluate the overall depth and quality of a blog as a whole not by a particular post. Rubistar is a website which contains a vast array of rubric templates to choose from or allows you to create and save your own. http://rubistar.4teachers.org/index.php
By incorporating the use of rubrics in your classes, you can alleviate those posts which begin and end with “I agree with Bill”. In the end, you can also help all students have the tools to succeed in your course.